Home › Resources › Blog › Meeting HR Challenges in a Multigenerational Workforce

Meeting HR Challenges in a Multigenerational Workforce

09/19/2025 – 13 min read

HR Leadership panel

By Ascendant and Lawley Insurance

Editor’s Note: This article originally appeared in Buffalo Business First

There is a wide variety of expectations put on employers these days. Just ask the baby boomers who are headed toward retirement, and Generation Z, who are just getting started and the two generations in between.

The mix is making the job of the human resources department increasingly complicated. Buffalo Business First Publisher John Tebeau recently gathered area experts to discuss how to approach the personnel matters developing in the workplace.

Joining Tebeau were:

  • Collin Gehl, president of the Buffalo Niagara Human Resource Association and chief human resource officer at Say Yes Buffalo, with a background in organizational leadership
  • Brian Murphy, a partner at Lawley Insurance, overseeing the employee benefits division with an expertise in self-funded health insurance
  • Lindsey Zajac, owner and CEO of Ascendant, a leadership development, career transition and executive search firm. Her background is in corporate HR and leadership development

Increasing Costs

Community rates, affecting employers under 100 employees, have seen significant increases in recent years and will continue to do so in 2026, Murphy said.

Adding to expected increases are specialty pharmaceuticals, which are trending at an appreciable rate and without warning, Murphy said. For example, a new drug for cystic fibrosis that didn’t exist a year ago costs $300,000.

There is also a spike in costs from care, diagnostic tests and treatment delayed during the pandemic.

“Employers need to take matters into their own hands and review their plan design and contributions to employee coverage,” he said.

There are a number of cost-containment options for employers, he said. Employers may consider captives, which are gaining popularity across the county. Captives become the sole insurers for a combination of companies of similar industries or risk levels. Participating companies buy stop loss protection as a group and that limits their risk, Murphy said.

Small- or medium-sized companies might benefit from being pooled in professional employment organizations, or PEOs. There are various drug formularies and possible carve-outs for certain medications, such as GLP-1 drugs for weight loss.

Gaining some momentum in the past few years are individual coverage health reimbursement arrangements, ICHRAs, in which employers reimburse workers for part or all the premiums for health insurance they bought on their own, Murphy said.

“What we’re seeing is employers are saying they are going to be more proactive in managing their plan,” Murphy said. “There are more solutions out there than there’s ever been. You need to find the right data that helps you make the right decision to control your costs and it’s specific to each employer. That’s where the large-group market is going.”

The small-group market, because of the restrictions in New York State and in most states, is going to have to hope that health insurance companies can “bend the trend a little bit,” he said.

New York State places mandates on health insurance and every mandate increases costs, he said. A self-insured plan, however, falls under federal government mandates only.

“What employers have to do is understand what their options are and determine what type of path they want to go down from a risk perspective and from an employee disruption perspective, because the costs are just escalating,” Murphy said. “That’s the future of managing these costs.”

Employees need to be informed consumers as well, Zajac said.

“As a small business owner, I do the best I can, but I really try to educate my team that they are consumers of their health benefits,” she said. “If you want the Cadillac plan this is what it’s going to cost. I’m going to contribute X per month towards your premiums, so you decide how you want to handle that. If there’s a reason why you want the platinum or the gold plan by all means go for it, but if you picked maybe silver or bronze my contribution covers most of that monthly premium. How do you want to spend your money?”

Gehl said to help control costs Say Yes has pooled its resources with other nonprofit organizations into a health and wellness insurance consortium. While costs have increased Say Yes has not passed the expense on to employees for the past four years. Trends in health coverage, however, may have the staff picking up some of the cost of their coverage, he said.

The impact of rising costs could be felt the strongest by the younger members of the workforce who are dealing with health insurance as working professionals for the first time. Some have come from homes without insurance or covered by Medicaid, or they are 26 and coming off their parents’ plan.

“They don’t know any better, so once these changes hit, they are going to start to feel it,’ Gehl said.

The ideal would be a strategy that would reduce costs while improving health, Murphy said. For example, bringing weight-loss drugs to a more reasonable price and providing support services, such as behavior modification, that together would make weight loss last in the long term. 

“That could be a game changer for us,” he said. “Obviously, obesity is one of the largest problems in the country and it drives so many other medical conditions.”

Generational Shift

The pandemic-inspired gray wave of baby boomers retiring from the workplace will continue at a rapid pace during the next five years, leaving millennials, those born between 1981 and 1996, and Generation Z, born between 1997 and 2010, making up most of the workforce.

“We have to think about how our organizations are structured and set up, because we have to appease all of these different generations,” Zajac said. “If you think about it, who was at the head of these companies when policies and rules were initiated? A lot of them were the baby boomer generation, but now we have to create workplaces for younger generations.”

She recommended having the baby boomers mentor who is coming up in their place. As the most experienced people on staff, they should teach, train, coach and develop younger generations to capture some of that knowledge.

At the very least, capture the baby boomers’ know-how, document it and create standard operating procedures based on whatever valuable information that could be lost once they leave the organization.

Look ahead to see who of the younger generation could fill leadership roles that the boomers are vacating. Zajac noted that trends indicate younger generations don’t really want to take on those leadership roles for variety of reasons, including the stress, pressure and responsibility of leadership and the need for work-life balance.

“Think about how to make leadership more appealing to them or how to equip them with skills so they feel more empowered to take on those roles in a way that works for them,” Zajac said.

Pay & Benefits

The next generations have confidence in themselves and want the pay and benefits, especially flexible work hours to match what they believe is the value they bring to the workplace.

They will leave an organization for another that will give them a slight nudge higher in pay or maybe an extra flex day, Gehl said.

Their attitude is an extension of the democratic way they were raised in which they were given choices and allowed to make decisions for themselves, Zajac said.

“They are used to being part of the conversation or having more of a voice and having more agency,” Zajac said.

Leadership’s role then is to educate them beyond the Internet search they did for common salaries for their job title and have them understand the determining factors, she said.

“There are salary ranges for a reason,” she said. “The top of the range is meant for people that have the most experience, the most expertise and are the most capable in the role. So if you’re 22-years-old, you don’t belong at the top of the range. One day you’ll get there.”

The panelists said the younger workers need help with interpersonal skills to interact with clients or customers. They also insist on greater and consistent support than previous generations, which can mean more proactive outreach, checking in with them more often and not waiting for them to go to leadership with an issue.

Attracting Talent

A recent trend in interviewing job candidates is to assess their intangible skills, Zajac said. Technical skills can be taught and can be demonstrated, unlike emotional intelligence. Use behavioral-based interview questions to get an assessment.

If an employee doesn’t work out on the job, Zajac said, it is never for lack of technical skills. It is always behavioral, so it is important to determine just how emotionally intelligent the candidate is.

“It’s how they talk to someone they don’t get along with, how well they handle a customer, that’s the stuff you’re trying to hire for because it’s harder to teach,” Zajac said. “That is what you should be focused on. How you talk to somebody, hold the door open for somebody, say hello to the receptionist and wait patiently in the waiting room, do you shake someone’s hand, and do you look them in the eye.”

Companies can get a sense of whether the job candidate would be a good fit in the company culture by using the Workplace Big Five Profile during interviews, she said. The assessment identifies five core personality dimensions: openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness and neuroticism, or negative emotions.

Zajac puts much weight on the standard interview question: Do you have any questions for me?

“If they don’t have questions, that’s a huge red flag,” she said. “It shows me they are not that interested, they can’t think on your toes, that they don’t have the critical thinking skills to come up with something to show you’re interested.”

Another red flag is questions about compensation and benefits that come too early in the conversation, she said.

At Say Yes, the hiring team tries to determine whether candidates are empathetic and are able to work with people of different generations and cultures and be able to do it effectively, Gehl said.

“When someone is in the talent acquisition and recruitment process, they are presumably putting their best foot forward,” he said. “If their best foot is not getting back to somebody right away, or it’s clear they haven’t reviewed our mission and values or they’re running a little bit late with no context, then think about when they get in the role and they get relaxed. It’s just going to be worse. Those are things that we really worked with our hiring teams to keep an eye out for.”

Company Culture 

Company culture expresses the values and the mission of an organization. It determines the environment and the behaviors that are accepted or rejected. It can also influence the success of the business.

Perhaps your company culture is similar to what was built into Lawley Insurance. It included co-workers grabbing lunch or joining others for happy hour or dinner. It was an enjoyable aspect of office life at the family-owned business, Murphy said.

The pandemic put an end to all that in-person collegiality, and the leadership felt the remote world was chipping away at the company culture. A culture committee was formed and meets monthly with partners and principals to address the post-Covid workplace.

“The world has changed, and so now we have events that fit different employees where they are,” Murphy said. “We have to work hard to make sure that we make them feel included,” which extends to remote workers as far away as Kansas and Wisconsin.

The events are meant to be fun and ultimately to coalesce staff.

“When you go to work you know we’re all in this together,” Murphy said. “We’re all going to work hard as a team.”

The Experts

Collin Gehl, President, Buffalo Niagara Human Resource Association. Collin Gehl has been with Say Yes Buffalo since 2019. He currently serves as the Chief Human Resources Officer. In that role, Collin is responsible for the overall administration of the HR Department. He ensures that HR supports the agency’s strategic and business plans, while complying with all federal, state, and local employment regulations. In addition, Collin sits on the agency’s Senior Leadership Team, oversees all agency training, hiring practices, and the salary/market assessments. Collin facilitates the organization’s professional development programs Leadership 101, 201 and 301. Leadership 101 won SHRMLab’s Better Workplace Challenge Cup in 2023.

Collin is the President of the Board of Directors of the Buffalo Niagara Human Resource Association. He has a Bachelor’s Degree in English from the University at Buffalo and a Master’s Degree in Organizational Leadership from Medaille University. Collin is also on the board of directors for Just Buffalo Literary Center.

Brian Murphy, Partner, Lawley Insurance. Brian oversees the growth, service, and operations of Lawley’s Employee Benefits division, encompassing more than 100 employees.

He provides consultative services to large employers, specializing in comprehensive benefits assessment, cost-control strategies, compliance and legislative guidance, self-funding across all benefit plans, and intricate benefits administration solutions. His deep understanding of compliance and legislative issues empowers employers to navigate and prepare for impacts on their health plans effectively.

Brian is a Canisius University alum where he was inducted into the DiGamma Honor Society and serves as the chair of the board of trustees. He has chaired Big Brothers Big Sisters of Erie, Niagara, and the Southern Tier and was a former board member of ConnectLife and Leadership Buffalo.

Brian was recognized in Buffalo Business First 40 under 40, awarded the Robert F. Moss Distinguished Service Award, and was appointed to the Regional Advisory Committee representing Western New York.

Lindsey Zajac, Owner and CEO, Ascendant. Lindsey A. Zajac is the Owner and CEO of Ascendant, a talent solutions firm dedicated to elevating careers, empowering leaders, and enriching lives through outplacement, search, and leadership services.

Founded in 1986, Ascendant has been a key player in recruiting, retaining, and transitioning talent in WNY.

Lindsey’s background includes 15 years in corporate HR roles at companies like PepsiCo and Eaton Corporation. In 2018, she shifted her focus to leadership training and development, joining Ahern, Murphy & Associates as a principal. Lindsey’s expertise spans leadership development, coaching, and talent management. She holds an Advanced Coaching Certification in Women’s Leadership and an Executive Leadership Certificate from Cornell. In 2025, she joined the Forbes Coaches Council and graduated from the CEL CORE Program. Lindsey graduated cum laude from Providence College with a BA in Political Science. She currently serves on the Board of the Buffalo Niagara Sales and Marketing Executives.